As I’m trying my best to “stick with the programme” I’ve been an avid viewer of all the diet/healthy programmes on TV that I can find. I have to say that most of these shows will either make me roll my eyes to heaven or in some cases they’ll be so crap that they make my blood boil, but I watch them nonetheless because I need the motivation. One of the latest I’ve come across is Supersize vs Superskinny on Channel 4 and I’m afraid for the most part it falls under the “making my blood boil” category.
The basic story is they get one supersize person and one superskinny person, both being very unhealthy in the extreme and each has to eat each other’s diets for a week. While in some respects it might be a helpful exercise to point out the error of a person’s ways, the whole presentation and feel of the show is just plain sick really. For a start there’s the title sequence which has cross sections of naked bodies, large and small, but with the genitals blanked out in a Barbie and Ken sort of way. Then there’s the (Gillian) McKeith style pile up of all the food consumed in a week, except it’s chucked down a chute into a tall Willy Wonka-esque pipe thingy. The aforementioned “Dr” McKeith also features in an effort to “Ban Big Bums” where she goes around the UK stripping women down to their underwear and getting them to bear their arses while she does her Chief Sgt Major act on them. Then to top it off our Gillian has a mini section where she gets people to guess calories and really there’s no point to it because one week something like a Cornish pastie had less calories than fish and pasta???
In the end it shows whether the supersize person has lost weight, whether the superskinny person has gained any and of course good old Gillian delivers the bum downsizing verdict. Oh and there’s another little segment of a guinea pig reporter woman trying out different dieting methods – from what I’ve seen so far she’ll be lucky to emerge alive – the first one I saw had her getting this “liposuction during your lunchbreak” kind of idea where she ended up with only one arm done that ended up bleeding profusely, later turning black and blue. Another time she got a massage and she pooed afterwards resulting in losing a few pounds. This week she interviewed a woman who pooed out all of her excess body fat.
Programmes like this quite honestly scare the crap out of me (no pun intended haha). Leaving aside the dangers attached to trying all of those silly things above, none of the people involved are portrayed to have learned anything at all, there are no lifestyle changes whatsoever. That scares me because of the effect it could have on people watching – yes they show some dangers like the problem with unlicensed diet pills and Gillian gives her spiel about what the healthy stuff is but I’m afraid that I can’t help thinking that many people would walk away thinking that okay diet pills are dangerous but hey they work and that they might as well have that Cornish pastie instead of fish because “it said on the telly” that it had less calories. With all the supposed governmental efforts there are at the moment to combat obesity it scares me that there aren’t sufficient regulations in place to ensure that the information being put out on TV and elsewhere is in fact correct. But then again, who am I kidding?!
Rant rant rant…….